Shop All Colored Diamonds

Shop our entire selection of beautiful colored diamonds below.

Sort By
 
 
$449.99
Sterling silver Infinity x Infinity pendant with 33 round single cut black diamonds weighing approximately 1/4 ct. tw. and 33 round brilliant cut diamonds weighing approximately 1/4 ct. tw.

18 inch sterling silver box chain

15x7 millimeters
CLEARANCE
 
Was: $499.99 Now: $399.99
This elegant sterling silver ring features a sparkling array of 21 round single cut white diamonds weighing approximately 1/8 ct. tw. and 30 round brilliant cut blue diamonds weighing approximately 3/8 ct. tw.
CLEARANCE
 
Was: $299.99 Now: $249.99
Crafted skillfully from sterling silver and 14K yellow gold, this adorable penguin pendant features round single cut round white diamonds and round black diamonds weighing approximately 1/4 ct. tw.

18 inch sterling silver box chain
CLEARANCE
 
Was: $399.99 Now: $249.99
Crafted from sterling silver, this glimmering bracelet features an eye-catching collection of black diamonds weighing approximately 1/5 ct. tw.

7 inches in length
CLEARANCE
 
Was: $399.99 Now: $249.99
This alluring sterling silver ring features round brilliant cut white diamonds and round brilliant cut blue diamonds weighing approximately 3/8 ct. tw.
 
 
$499.99
This sterling silver band, which is adorned with 9 round brilliant cut black diamonds weighing approximately 1 ct. tw., will give you a sharp look.
CLEARANCE
 
Was: $999.99 Now: $799.99
These stunning earrings are made from 14K yellow gold and embellished with a sparkling mix of round brilliant cut white diamonds, black diamonds and champagne diamonds weighing approximately 1/2 ct. tw.
CLEARANCE
 
Was: $129.99 Now: $99.99
Grandness in simplicity is portrayed to perfection in this sterling silver promise ring, which showcases 1 round black diamond weighing approximately 1/4 ct.
PRE-OWNED
 
Was: $499.99 Now: $420.00
Sterling silver band with 9 round brilliant cut black diamonds weighing approximately 1 ct. tw.

Our previously owned jewelry is hand-inspected to ensure you receive a high-quality piece of jewelry at the greatest possible value.

All pre-owned sales are final.
CLEARANCE
 
Was: $1,299.00 Now: $699.99
Featuring a captivating array of black, blue and white diamonds weighing approximately 1 ct. tw., this 10K white gold ring make a chic addition to your jewelry collection.
CLEARANCE
 
Was: $499.99 Now: $329.99
Sterling silver and 10K rose gold cluster stud earrings with 14 round brilliant cut champagne diamonds weighing approximately 1/5 ct. tw. and 40 round single cut white diamonds weighing approximately 1/8 ct. tw.
CLEARANCE
 
Was: $599.99 Now: $399.99
Add a modern touch to your ensemble with these sterling silver stud earrings, which feature a cluster of round brilliant cut diamonds weighing approximately 1/4 ct. surrounded by a halo of 16 round single cut black diamonds weighing approximately 1/5 ct. tw.
ONLINE ONLY SAVINGS
 
Was: $99.99 Now: $79.99
Sterling silver bar bracelet with 20 round single cut black diamonds weighing approximately 1/10 ct. tw.

7.25 inches in length
 
 
$399.99
10K yellow gold stud earrings with 2 round brilliant cut natural yellow diamonds weighing approximately 1/2 ct. tw. and four 1.1 millimeter round garnets
 
 
$1,999.00
Beauty at its finest, this sublime 14K white and yellow gold pendant is adorned with 1 pear-shaped yellow diamond weighing approximately 1/4 ct., 19 round yellow diamonds weighing approximately 1/10 ct. tw. and 42 round white diamonds weighing approximately 1/7 ct. tw.

18 inch 14K white gold venetian box chain
CLEARANCE
 
Was: $349.99 Now: $269.99
Sterling silver ring with 8 round brilliant cut blue diamonds weighing approximately 1/7 ct. tw. and 36 round single cut white diamonds weighing approximately 1/5 ct. tw.
 
 
$499.99
Stand out from the crowd with this dashing bracelet, which is made from stainless steel with black ion plating and features 100 round brilliant cut blue diamonds weighing approximately 1/2 ct. tw.

8.5 inches in length
 
 
$349.99
Simple yet dapper, this black tungsten 8 millimeter band is designed with 1 round brilliant cut black diamond accent.
CLEARANCE
 
Was: $499.99 Now: $329.99
Sterling silver diamond square shaped dangle earrings with 82 round single cut diamonds weighing approximately 1/3 ct. tw. and 14 round single cut blue diamonds weighing approximately 1/5 ct. tw.
 
 
$49.99
Crafted from sterling silver, this magical 9.36x6.34 millimeter owl pendant is adorned with 2 round black diamond accents and 4 round white diamond accents.

17 inch sterling silver curb chain
 
 
$749.99
This sterling silver and 10K rose gold bangle features a shimmering array of 53 round single cut natural champagne diamonds weighing approximately 1/3 ct. tw.
 
 
$429.99
Edgy yet elegant, this 10K white gold 6 millimeter halo pendant features 1 round black diamond weighing approximately 1/2 ct. and 20 round single cut white diamond accents.

18 inch 10K white gold rope chain
 
 
$499.99
Embellished with 36 round single cut natural champagne diamonds weighing approximately 1/4 ct. tw. and 14 round single cut white diamond accents, these 10K yellow gold dangle earrings are an elegant essential.
 
 
$799.99
A dazzling treat to the eyes and heart, this beautiful 10K rose gold pendant is designed with 12 round single cut white diamonds weighing approximately 1/10 ct. tw., 16 round brilliant cut white diamonds weighing approximately 1/6 ct. tw. and 16 round brilliant cut champagne diamonds weighing approximately 1/5 ct. tw.

18 inch 10K white gold rope chain
CLEARANCE
 
Was: $149.99 Now: $119.99
This quirky sterling silver lizard pendant features 20 round single cut blue diamonds approximately 1/10 ct. tw. and 2 round single cut black diamond accents.

18 inch sterling silver venetian box chain
ONLINE ONLY SAVINGS
 
Was: $199.99 Now: $149.99
Add a dazzling element to your ensemble with these sterling silver 5 millimeter halo stud earrings, which features 2 round black diamonds weighing approximately 1/7 ct. tw. and 28 round white diamonds weighing approximately 1/10 ct. tw.
 
 
$1,399.00
14K rose gold ring with one 10x8 millimeter oval rhodolite garnet, 55 white single cut diamonds and 28 brown single cut diamonds weighing approximately 1/3 ct. tw.

Bordeaux Collection by EFFY®
CLEARANCE
 
Was: $299.99 Now: $249.99
Whimsical and adorable, this 10K white gold penguin pendant is designed with an array of black and white diamonds weighing approximately 1/6 ct. tw.

18 inch 10K white gold rope chain
 
 
$399.99
14K white gold contour band with 17 round single cut blue diamonds weighing approximately 1/8 ct. tw.
CLEARANCE
 
Was: $299.99 Now: $229.99
This chic sterling silver bangle bracelet features an array of round single cut black diamonds weighing approximately 1/7 ct. tw.
CLEARANCE
 
Was: $179.99 Now: $129.99
Crafted from sterling silver, this unique band features 8 round white diamond accents and 12 round single cut blue diamond accents.
 
 
$199.99
This elegant sterling silver and 10K rose gold ring features 1 round brilliant cut natural champagne diamond accent and 22 round single cut white diamonds weighing approximately 1/10 ct. tw.
CLEARANCE
 
Was: $189.99 Now: $129.99
A perfect token of love that knows no bounds, this 23x21 millimeter sterling silver heart pendant is designed with 22 round green diamonds weighing approximately 1/10 ct. tw. and 36 round white diamonds weighing approximately 1/10 ct. tw.

18 inch sterling silver venetian box chain
 
 
$549.99
Crafted from sterling silver and 10K rose gold, this vintage-inspired band is adorned with 13 round brilliant cut champagne diamonds weighing approximately 1/3 ct. tw. and 34 round single cut white diamonds weighing approximately 1/7 ct. tw.
 
 
$399.99
The gorgeous arrangement of black and white diamonds on an artistic scroll design gives this sterling silver ring a beauty reminiscent of a full moon shining bright in a cloudless sky.
CLEARANCE
 
Was: $329.99 Now: $199.99
A perfect representation of style meets simplicity, this sterling silver crisscross bangle bracelet features 20 round black diamonds weighing approximately 1/7 ct. tw. and 25 round white diamonds weighing approximately 1/7 ct. tw

7.25 inches
  • NARROW BY:
  • Reset
    Gender
    • Women (497)
    • Men (68)
  • Reset
    Item Type
    • Rings (280)
    • Necklaces (183)
    • Earrings (67)
    • Bracelets (23)
    • Other (8)
    • Watches (3)
  • Reset
    Price Range
    • Under $100 (59)
    • $100 - $199 (78)
    • $200 - $399 (129)
    • $400 - $699 (89)
    • $700 - $999 (55)
    • $1000 - $1999 (90)
    • $2000 - $2999 (46)
    • $3000 - $4999 (15)
    • $5000 - $9999 (3)
    • Over $10000 (1)
  • Reset
    Stone Type
    • Diamond (Fancy) (286)
    • Diamond (231)
    • Gemstone (35)
    • Pearl (1)
  • Reset
    Stone Shape
    • Round (470)
    • Cushion (27)
    • Oval (23)
    • Square (14)
    • Pear (5)
    • Rectangular (4)
    • Fancy (2)
    • Off Round (1)
  • Reset
    Metal
    • Gold (301)
    • Silver (241)
    • Stainless Steel (10)
    • Tungsten (5)
  • Reset
    Metal Color
    • Silver (242)
    • White (166)
    • Rose (96)
    • Yellow (47)
    • Black (6)
    • Gray (1)
  • Reset
    Watch Style
    • Casual (2)
    • Sport (1)
  • Reset
    Watch Band Color
    • Black (2)
    • Silver (1)
  • Reset
    Collections
    • Sparkling Champagne (71)
    • Espresso Collection by EFFY® (13)
    • Circle of Love (8)
    • The Beat of Your Heart (8)
    • Bordeaux Collection by EFFY® (7)
    • Colored Diamonds (6)
    • Aquaris Collection by EFFY® (5)
    • Blush Collection by EFFY® (5)
    • I Am Loved Bridal (5)
    • Helzberg Diamond Symphonies (4)
    • Helzberg Limited Edition (4)
    • Triton (4)
    • Caviar Collection by EFFY® (3)
    • Gucci G-Timeless (2)
    • Tanzanite RoyalĂ© Collection by EFFY® (2)
    • Beat of Your Heart (1)
    • Gucci G-Chrono (1)