If you’ve ever been on the search for diamonds, you know that they’re not all created equal. Whether you’re inspired by a timeless love story — or one that’s been freshly written all over social media — understanding the nuances between Old European-cut diamonds vs. round brilliant can help you pick the perfect ring that fits your personality and reflects your love.
The history of diamond cuts
Old cuts have a story to tell. Crafted by hand in the 18th and 19th centuries, they feature fewer facets and a softer glow. These diamonds are like that favorite lyric that sticks in your head for days. They’re also subtle, romantic and completely unique. These old-diamond cuts possess the kind of sparkle that feels vintage, like that song you’d play on repeat.
Modern, brilliant cuts didn’t ascend the popularity charts until the early 20th century. Engineered to maximize light and dazzle with 57 or 58 facets, these more modern-cut diamonds get your attention, whether you’re walking into a flower-filled space or catching eyes across the field.
Defining features of old diamond cuts
Old cuts are perfect if you love a hint of nostalgia, the kind of sparkle that tells a story without saying a word, and makes every glance feel enchanted. Here are a few characteristics that define timeless, old diamond cuts:
- Handcrafted with fewer, larger facets
- Rounded shapes with slightly imperfect symmetry
- Soft, romantic glow rather than all-out dazzle
- Antique charm, like a secret kept all too well.
Defining features of modern brilliant cuts
Brilliant cuts are for those who want their diamond to shine as bright as a spotlight and make an entrance that everyone remembers. Key features of modern brilliant cuts include:
- Precision-cut facets for maximum fire and brilliance
- Perfect symmetry and dazzling sparkle
- Popular and instantly recognizable shapes, especially round
- All the drama and shine you’d expect from a headline-making moment
Key differences between brilliant and old cuts
Want a breakdown of the differences between old and newer? Here’s a handy guide:
| Feature | Old Cuts | Brilliant Cuts |
|---|---|---|
| Facets | Fewer, larger | 57 to 58, engineered for sparkle |
| Light Performance | Gentle, romantic glow | Maximum brilliance and fire6 |
| Shape | Often round or cushion | Round is standard; others available |
| Symmetry | Handcrafted, unique | Precision-cut, flawless |
| Appeal | Vintage charm, nostalgic | Modern, head-turning |
Which one should you choose?
Whether you choose the subtle romance of an old cut or the dazzling brilliance of a modern cut, the right diamond will always feel like a “moment of magic.” Here are a few of our favorite rings and diamond shapes:
- Go for the touchdown by proposing with the brilliance of a round solitaire diamond with a white gold band.
- Fall in love with the look of an elongated cushion-cut diamond featuring emerald-cut side stones for geometric sparkle.
- Add a modern blush of rose gold metal to a classic elongated center stone embellished with tasteful side stones trailing along the band.
Whether you go with an old mine cut vs. brilliant diamond, you’ll see sparks fly when you make the commitment to the one you love most.