20% off sitewide. No code needed.

ENDS 2/8

for more information on this promotion, see our current promo details page. See Details
Valentine's Day Sale. Up to 40% off select styles. No code needed.

ENDS 2/17

for more information on this promotion, see our current promo details page. See Details
15% off select Movado watches. No code needed.

ENDS 2/14

for more information on this promotion, see our current promo details page. See Details
Buy 3, get 1 free. Amulet charms collection. No code needed.

ENDS 2/17

for more information on this promotion, see our current promo details page. See Details
I am loved collection. 2 for $149.99. Reg. $99.99 each. No code needed.

ENDS 2/17

for more information on this promotion, see our current promo details page. See Details
LAB CREATED GEMSTONE BRACELETS Buy 2, Get 1 FREE REG. $99.99 EACH No code needed

ENDS 2/17

for more information on this promotion, see our current promo details page. See Details
$150 off $999+. $300 off $1,999+. code: CELEBRATE

ONLINE ONLY

for more information on this promotion, see our current promo details page. See Details
15% off engagement rings $1,999+. Code: YES15

ONLINE ONLY

for more information on this promotion, see our current promo details page. See Details
$50 off $299.99+. Code: TAKE50

ONLINE ONLY

for more information on this promotion, see our current promo details page. See Details
25% off Outlet. No code needed.

ENDS 2/8

for more information on this promotion, see our current promo details page. See Details
February Birthstone. Up to $200 off select amethyst styles. No code needed.

ENDS 2/28

for more information on this promotion, see our current promo details page. See Details
Free Expedited shipping on orders $99+. No code needed.

LIMITED TIME ONLY

for more information on this promotion, see our current promo details page. See Details
All deals see more. No code needed.

LIMITED TIME ONLY

for more information on this promotion, see our current promo details page. See Details

Unique Gemstone Engagement Rings

Our selection of unique gemstone engagement rings offers affordable sparkle and exquisite beauty, with both color and colorless options for the bride-to-be who wants something less traditional.

null

Filter By

Making a selection with these checkboxes will cause content on this page to change. Product listings will update as each option is selected.

Zac Posen Margaux Rose de France Amethyst Engagement Ring with Diamonds in 14K Yellow Gold (3/4 ct. tw.)

Price reduced from $2,799.00 to $2,239.20
Discount reflected in price
Metal :
14K Yellow Gold

Zac Posen Olivia London Blue Topaz & Diamond Engagement Ring in 14K yellow gold (7/8 ct. tw.)

Price reduced from $2,799.00 to $2,239.20
Discount reflected in price
Metal :
14K Yellow Gold

Charles & Colvard-Forever One™ Emerald-Cut Lab Created Moissanite Ring with Side-Stones in 14K Yellow Gold

Price reduced from $949.99 to $759.99
Discount reflected in price

Charles & Colvard-Forever One™ Lab-Created Moissanite Solitaire Engagement Ring in 14K Yellow Gold (3 ct. dew)

Price reduced from $1,799.00 to $1,439.20
Discount reflected in price

Radiant-Cut Moissanite Ring with Knife-Edge Band in 14K White Gold (2 ct. dew)

Price reduced from $1,199.00 to $959.20
Discount reflected in price

Charles & Colvard-Forever One™ Hearts & Arrows Moissanite Ring with Halo in 14K White Gold (2 7/8 ct. dew)

Price reduced from $1,199.00 to $959.20
Discount reflected in price

Round Lab Created White Sapphire Ring in 10K White Gold

Price reduced from $749.99 to $599.99
Discount reflected in price

Zac Posen Flora Moss Agate and Diamond Engagement Ring in 14K White & Yellow Gold (3/8 ct. tw.)

Price reduced from $2,299.00 to $1,839.20
Discount reflected in price
Metal :
14K White Gold

Charles & Colvard-Forever One™ Lab-Created Moissanite Engagement Ring in 14K Yellow Gold (2 5/8 ct. dew)

Price reduced from $1,199.00 to $959.20
Discount reflected in price

Charles & Colvard-Forever One™ Round Moissanite Solitaire Ring in 14K White Gold (1 ct. dew)

Price reduced from $729.99 to $583.99
Discount reflected in price

Charles & Colvard-Forever One™ Lab-Created Moissanite Engagement Ring in 14K White Gold (1 1/3 ct. dew)

Price reduced from $849.99 to $679.99
Discount reflected in price

Charles & Colvard-Forever One™ Oval Moissanite Halo Ring in 14K White Gold (1 7/8 ct. dew)

Price reduced from $849.99 to $679.99
Discount reflected in price

Charles & Colvard-Forever One™ Moissanite Oval Ring in 14K Yellow Gold

Price reduced from $949.99 to $759.99
Discount reflected in price

Shades of Love Round Morganite Ring with Diamond Band in 14K Rose Gold (1/3 ct. tw.)

Price reduced from $1,799.00 to $1,439.20
Discount reflected in price

Charles & Colvard-Forever One™ Cushion-Cut Moissanite Halo Ring with Pavé Band in 14K White Gold (2 7/8 ct. dew)

Price reduced from $1,099.00 to $879.20
Discount reflected in price

Shades of Love Morganite & 1/3 ct. tw. Diamond Ring in 14K Rose Gold

Price reduced from $2,499.00 to $1,999.20
Discount reflected in price

Charles & Colvard-Forever One™ Lab Created Moissanite Twist-Shank Multi-Stone Engagement Ring in 14K White Gold

Price reduced from $1,199.00 to $959.20
Discount reflected in price

Zac Posen Kate Aquamarine & Diamond Engagement Ring in 14K White Gold (3/4 ct. tw.)

Price reduced from $2,499.00 to $1,999.20
Discount reflected in price
Metal :
14K White Gold

Charles & Colvard-Forever One™ Radiant-Cut Moissanite Halo Ring in 14K White Gold (3 ct. dew)

Price reduced from $1,899.00 to $1,519.20
Discount reflected in price

Charles & Colvard-Forever One™ Round Moissanite Solitaire Ring in 14K White Gold (3 ct. dew)

Price reduced from $1,899.00 to $1,519.20
Discount reflected in price

Pear-Shaped Lab Created White Sapphire Ring in 10K White Gold

Price reduced from $799.99 to $639.99
Discount reflected in price

Charles & Colvard-Forever One™ Moissanite Oval Halo Ring in 14K White Gold (3 1/3 ct. dew)

Price reduced from $1,199.00 to $959.20
Discount reflected in price

Shades of Love Lab-Created Oval-Shaped Alexandrite Ring in 14K Yellow Gold (1/3 ct. tw.)

Price reduced from $1,499.00 to $1,199.20
Discount reflected in price

Charles & Colvard-Forever One™ Oval Moissanite Solitaire Ring in 14K White Gold (2 ct. dew)

Price reduced from $1,199.00 to $959.20
Discount reflected in price

Choosing The Perfect Colored Gemstone Engagement Ring

Looking for the best gemstones for engagement rings? Radiating vibrant color, ranging from deep blue to light yellow, each gemstone glitters with breathtaking brilliance. Available in a rainbow of eye-catching hues, Helzberg offers a range of precious and semi-precious gemstone options, perfect to express your eternal love.

  • Liven their ring with a regal green emerald or a paler jade-green amethyst stone, surrounded by a halo of diamonds.
  • Match the color in your fiancé-to-be’s eyes with a series of light-catching three-stone aquamarine ring outlined in diamonds, or try a solitaire aquamarine gemstone ring.
  • Capture the shades of love with a romantic pink morganite engagement ring featuring a radiant cut and warm, yellow gold band for maximum sparkle and reflection.
  • Create your own gemstone engagement ring with various stones for a multicolor effect by using our custom tool.
  • Achieve a fiery rainbow sparkle with the diamond-like aesthetic of a near-colorless moissanite engagement ring with an emerald-cut stone and coordinating white gold band.

Whether you choose a round cut or a cushion style to accentuate the engagement ring, you’ll find these unique gemstone engagement rings in any array of styles, colors, cuts and price points. Book a consultation with Helzberg today.

FAQs

What gemstones are good for engagement rings?

Diamonds are the most popular choice for engagement rings due to their durability and brilliance. But other exquisite gemstone options include sapphires, rubies and moissanite, which offer both beauty and strength for everyday wear.

What is the hardest gemstone?

Diamond is the hardest gemstone, ranking 10 on the Mohs scale of mineral hardness. Sapphire and rubies also rank 9 on the scale, making them excellent everyday choices for colored gemstone engagement rings.